remipay
    Work Insights

    How agencies review contractor hours before paying (timesheet approval that holds up)

    RemiPay Team··10 min read

    Review contractor hours before each pay run by grouping them by client and project, checking them against the agreed estimate or cap and the client invoice, fixing errors, and recording who approved each line and when. Do it in one sitting per cycle, before any money moves, and treat it as a billing check, not a judgment of the person.

    This guide sets out the method agencies can use for timesheet approval, the signals that hours are over- or under-billed, and a fictional worked example. It is written for teams of roughly 3 to 50 contractors, where the owner or an account lead still looks at every pay run. RemiPay is built around this step: it prepares the recurring pay run and shows what the paid hours produced, by client and project, before the founder approves; the owner then pays from their own Wise Business account and marks each payment paid in RemiPay. Hours come from Hubstaff (connected by OAuth or a personal access token), from RemiPay's built-in RemiStaff tracker, or from manual timesheets.

    Why review hours before the pay run, not after

    Once a transfer is sent, fixing a wrong amount means asking a contractor to send money back or netting it against next month. Both are awkward, and both leave a messy record for your accountant. A review before approval costs less time than one correction after.

    There is also a revenue reason. Agency margin lives in the gap between what you pay contractors and what you bill clients. If hours are logged against the wrong client, or not logged at all, that gap is invisible until the month is closed. Reviewing by client and project is what makes it visible.

    What you need before you start

    Input Where it usually lives Why it matters in the review
    Contractor agreement or statement of work Contract folder Rate, currency, caps, what counts as billable
    Hours entries (date, client, project, hours, billable flag) Time tracker or timesheet The thing you are approving
    Project estimate or monthly retainer hours Proposal or project tracker The benchmark for over or under
    Client invoice or billing draft Accounting or invoicing tool What the client will actually pay for
    Named approver Your own policy Who signs off, and who can be asked later

    If you do not have hours in one place yet, start with the contractor timesheet and pay-run template, which has these columns.

    The five-step review

    1. Group every entry by client, then project. Look at totals per project first, not per person. A project total that is far off its estimate tells you where to look.
    2. Compare with the estimate, retainer or cap. For each project, check logged hours against the budget. Note anything more than a small margin over or under.
    3. Compare with the client invoice. Mark each hour as billable or non-billable. Billable hours should appear on a client invoice or a change order. Non-billable hours should be ones you agreed to pay for, such as internal work or approved pitches.
    4. Fix errors and ask questions. Remove duplicates, move hours logged to the wrong client, and ask the contractor about anything unexplained. Return entries with a note rather than editing silently.
    5. Approve and record. Approve the hours that are settled. Record the approver, the date and any adjustments. Lines still under discussion stay out of this run or go in as pending.

    In RemiPay, manually entered hours wait for the founder's approval, while Hubstaff hours arrive already approved, so if you use Hubstaff, do this review before you open the run. Only the account owner (the founder) approves the run, with 2FA, and RemiPay records who approved and when.

    Signals of over-billed and under-billed hours

    Over-billing and under-billing are both common, and under-billing is easier to miss because nothing looks wrong.

    Signal Likely cause What to do
    Project total well over estimate Scope creep, client requests outside the plan, or rework Ask for context; if the client asked for more, raise a change order
    Same hours on the same date twice Duplicate entry or import error Remove the duplicate and tell the contractor
    Hours on a client the contractor was not assigned to Wrong project selected Move the entry to the right client before billing
    Work delivered but few or no hours logged Contractor forgot to log, or logs at month end from memory Ask them to submit the hours; the client may be under-billed too
    Retainer client using far fewer hours than usual Real slowdown, or hours logged elsewhere Check with the account lead before the client renewal
    Non-billable hours climbing month on month Internal work growing without a decision Agree a monthly cap for non-billable time

    None of these is evidence that anyone did something wrong. Most are data entry problems or scope conversations that never happened.

    Client invoice and contractor pay are two different numbers

    A common mistake is assuming that approved contractor hours and billed client hours should match. They often should not:

    • Fixed-bid client work is billed at the agreed price, while the contractor is paid for the hours they were authorized to work.
    • Non-billable hours (internal, pitches, training) are paid but never invoiced.
    • Markup means the billed rate is higher than the contractor rate by design.
    • Capped retainers may stop billing at a ceiling while authorized work continues.

    The goal is to reconcile the two numbers, not force them to be equal. If a contractor worked hours you authorized, pay them, even when the client will not be billed. That is a pricing or scope issue to fix with the client. Set caps in the contractor agreement up front so the question rarely comes up.

    Billing hours are not a performance review

    Use the hours review for what it is: confirming that pay, client billing and the agreement line up. Do not quietly turn the same numbers into a performance score. Agency practitioners describe being blindsided when billing hours they logged for invoicing later appeared in a review of their work. People who expect that start logging defensively, and the data you rely on for billing gets worse.

    If you have a concern about quality or speed, raise it as a separate conversation about the work itself. Keep the approval notes factual: "6 hours over cap, held pending client change order," not "slow on this project."

    For independent contractors there is a further reason to keep the review about deliverables and scope. The IRS looks at whether a business controls what will be done and how it will be done when deciding if a worker is an employee, across behavioral, financial and relationship factors (IRS: independent contractor or employee). Checking hours against an agreed scope is a billing control; directing how someone works is a different thing. Ask a qualified advisor how this applies to your contractors.

    Reviewing AI-assisted work

    Some agencies now ask contractors to note when AI tools did part of the work, so the owner can see what paid hours produced and whether a project's estimate still makes sense. RemiPay shows AI usage alongside hours and approvals in the pre-approval view. Whatever you use, the same rule applies: it is context for pricing and estimates, not a performance metric, and contractors should know what is collected.

    Worked example: Kestrel Creative's October hours review

    This is a fictional, illustrative sample. Kestrel Creative, its clients and its contractors are invented, and the rates are round numbers.

    Kestrel Creative is a small U.S. agency paying three hourly contractors monthly: Priya (India, $30 per hour), Jonas (Germany, $55 per hour) and Carla (Argentina, $35 per hour). The account lead reviews October hours on November 3, and the owner approves the run the same day.

    Client Project Contractor Hours logged Hours approved for pay Hours billable to client Finding Action
    Acme Bakery Site maintenance Priya 19 19 19 Within 20-hour retainer Approve
    Ridge Outdoors Spring ads Jonas 52 52 52 (40 estimate + 12 change order) 12 hours over estimate; client asked for extra ad sets in writing Approve pay; send client a change order
    Ridge Outdoors Spring ads Carla 0 9 9 Assets delivered, hours not logged Carla submits 9 hours; approve
    Harbor Legal Copy edits Carla 14 11 11 Same 3-hour entry on Oct 14 logged twice Remove duplicate; approve 11
    Internal Pitch deck Jonas 6 6 0 Non-billable, agreed in advance Approve; not invoiced
    Total 91 97 91

    What the review changed, in pay terms:

    Contractor Approved hours Rate Approved amount (USD) Without review
    Priya 19 $30 $570 $570
    Jonas 58 $55 $3,190 $3,190
    Carla 20 $35 $700 $490 (14 logged hours, with the duplicate)

    Without the review, Carla would have been underpaid for real work and overpaid for a duplicate at the same time, and Ridge Outdoors would have been under-billed by 21 hours (12 extra from Jonas, 9 missing from Carla). The approval record reads: approved by the owner, November 3, two adjustments with notes. That record goes to the accountant with the pay run. For how the owner then pays the approved amounts from Wise, marks them paid and exports the record, see the sample contractor pay run.

    Common questions

    What is timesheet approval for contractors? Timesheet approval is the step where someone at the company checks a contractor's logged hours against the agreement, the project budget and the client invoice, then approves, adjusts or returns them before payment. The approver's name and date should be recorded.

    How do agencies track billable hours for contractors? Each entry needs a date, contractor, client, project, hours and a billable or non-billable flag. Grouping those entries by client and project each cycle lets you compare them with estimates and invoices before you pay.

    Should I pay contractor hours the client will not pay for? Usually yes, if the hours were authorized under the contractor's agreement. Unbilled hours are a pricing or scope problem with the client, not a reason to withhold contractor pay. Agree caps in advance to avoid the question.

    Does reviewing a contractor's hours make them an employee? Checking hours against an agreed scope and rate is a billing control. Classification depends on the overall relationship, including whether you direct how the work is done, so ask a qualified advisor about your situation.

    Who should approve contractor timesheets? The person who knows the client work, usually the account or project lead, should review the hours. The owner then approves the pay run (in RemiPay, only the account owner can approve). In small teams one person may do both, which makes the written trail more important.

    Sources

    Checked November 16, 2026

    Next steps

    timesheet approvalbillable hourscontractor paymentsagenciespay run
    RemiPay Team

    Posts from the RemiPay editorial team. Have a question or topic request? Email hello@remipay.co.