remipay
    Resources

    W-8BEN vs W-9: which form to ask your contractors for

    RemiPay Team··11 min read

    Ask for Form W-9 when the contractor is a U.S. person (a U.S. citizen, a resident alien or a U.S. company), wherever they live. Ask for Form W-8BEN when the contractor is a foreign individual, and Form W-8BEN-E when you pay a foreign company. You request and keep the form; none of the three is sent to the IRS. The deciding question is tax status, not the country on the invoice.

    This guide covers how to choose, what each form contains, when a form needs replacing, and how RemiPay collects the W-9 or W-8BEN at onboarding. It is general information based on IRS pages checked on the date below, not tax advice. Please have a tax professional review your own setup.

    The short answer in one table

    Form W-9 Form W-8BEN Form W-8BEN-E
    Who fills it out U.S. persons: U.S. citizens (including those abroad), resident aliens, U.S. partnerships, corporations and LLCs Foreign individuals (nonresident aliens) Foreign entities, such as a contractor's own company abroad
    What it does Gives you the contractor's correct taxpayer identification number (TIN) Certifies foreign status of the beneficial owner Documents a foreign entity's status for U.S. withholding purposes
    Key ID on the form SSN or EIN Foreign tax ID in most cases; a U.S. TIN only in limited cases Entity's tax IDs and classification
    Who keeps it You, the payer You, the payer or withholding agent You, the payer or withholding agent
    Sent to the IRS? No No No
    Current revision (per IRS) March 2024 October 2021 October 2021
    Expires? No set expiry; ask again if details change Generally end of the third calendar year after signing Has its own validity rules; see the W-8BEN-E instructions
    What it can lead to Form 1099-NEC if you pay $2,000 or more in a year (payments in 2026 and later) Usually no 1099-NEC; ask about other reporting Usually no 1099-NEC; ask about other reporting

    How to decide which form to ask for

    Work through these questions in order for each new contractor.

    1. Are you paying a person or a company? If the invoice comes from a company, the entity's status decides the form. If it comes from an individual, the person's status decides it.
    2. Is the person a U.S. citizen? If yes, it is a W-9, even if they have lived in Lisbon for ten years. The IRS defines a U.S. person to include U.S. citizens and resident aliens, and its W-8BEN instructions tell U.S. citizens and other U.S. persons to use Form W-9 instead.
    3. Is the person a U.S. resident alien? A green card holder, or someone who meets the substantial presence test for the year, is a resident alien for tax purposes and uses a W-9. If the contractor is not sure, they should check the IRS residency guidance or ask their own tax adviser; it is their status to certify, not yours to guess.
    4. Otherwise, the individual is a foreign person: W-8BEN. The IRS says a foreign person who is the beneficial owner of income subject to withholding gives the form to the payer when asked, even if they claim no reduced rate or exemption.
    5. For a company: a company organized in the U.S. (including an LLC) is a U.S. person and gives a W-9. A company organized abroad gives a W-8BEN-E. For a U.S. single-member LLC that is disregarded for tax purposes, the IRS requester instructions say the owner's name goes on line 1 and the LLC's name on line 2.

    Two related forms come up less often. Form W-8ECI is for income effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business, and the W-8BEN instructions point nonresident aliens claiming an exemption on pay for services performed in the United States to Form 8233 or Form W-4. If a foreign contractor will work while physically in the U.S., talk to a tax professional before the first payment.

    What changes after the form is signed

    A W-9 usually leads to a 1099-NEC. The IRS instructions for Form 1099-NEC say to report nonemployee compensation of $2,000 or more, a threshold that rose from $600 for tax years beginning after 2025. The form goes to the contractor and to the IRS by January 31. Your accountant will want the W-9 details to prepare it.

    A missing TIN means backup withholding. The IRS says payers must withhold at a flat 24% on reportable payments when a payee does not furnish a TIN, or when the IRS notifies the payer that the TIN is incorrect. The W-9 requester instructions add that a payer who fails to withhold can become liable for the amount. Collecting the W-9 before the first payment avoids the problem.

    A W-8BEN supports foreign status. The IRS says the source of personal service income is generally where the services are performed, so work done entirely outside the U.S. is generally foreign source. The W-8BEN is the document that shows why you treated a payment as going to a foreign person. The 1099 instructions point to Form 1042-S for certain U.S.-source payments to nonresident aliens; ask your tax professional whether any reporting applies to your foreign contractors.

    A W-8BEN expires. The IRS instructions say the form generally stays in effect from the signing date until the last day of the third succeeding calendar year, unless a change in circumstances makes it incorrect. A form signed on March 3, 2026 would generally run through December 31, 2029. The contractor must notify you within 30 days of a change, such as moving to the U.S. or becoming a U.S. citizen, and give you a new form.

    Worked example: a sample team of four contractors

    This is a sample, illustrative onboarding for a fictional U.S. agency. Names, places and amounts are invented. The form choices follow the IRS rules above; the reporting column is a prompt for the agency's accountant, not a conclusion.

    Contractor (fictional) Where they work Who is paid Tax status Form to collect Sample 2026 pay What to raise with the accountant
    Dana Whitfield Lisbon, Portugal Dana, as an individual U.S. citizen W-9 $18,000 Form 1099-NEC, since she is a U.S. person paid over $2,000
    Ana Reyes Manila, Philippines Ana, as an individual Foreign individual W-8BEN $14,400 Foreign-source services; confirm no U.S. reporting applies
    Brightline Studio sp. z o.o. Kraków, Poland A Polish company Foreign entity W-8BEN-E $22,000 Entity status as documented on the form
    Marcus Lee Austin, Texas Marcus's single-member LLC U.S. person (disregarded LLC) W-9, owner's name on line 1 $9,000 Form 1099-NEC, issued using the W-9 details

    Two details in this sample catch teams out. Dana lives abroad but is still a W-9, so a rule of "U.S. address means W-9" would get her wrong. Brightline is a company, so a W-8BEN (the individual form) would be the wrong document even though its founder is a foreign individual.

    For the W-8BEN, the agency also notes the expiry. Ana signed on March 3, 2026, so the agency diarizes a request for a new form before December 31, 2029.

    How RemiPay handles tax forms at onboarding

    RemiPay collects the tax form as part of contractor onboarding, alongside the signed agreement. Turning on the tax form for a contractor sends them the IRS form that matches their country: a W-9 for a contractor based in the U.S., a W-8BEN for everyone else. The founder can switch the requirement on or off per contractor, and a pay run that includes the contractor is blocked until every required document is signed. The form data is stored encrypted.

    Because the automatic choice is by country, check the two cases from the sample above yourself. A U.S. citizen living abroad needs a W-9 rather than the W-8BEN their country would suggest, and a foreign company needs a W-8BEN-E, which RemiPay does not generate. For either, have the contractor complete the IRS form directly and keep it with your records.

    The tax form sits next to the rest of the run, and the cost of each part is separate:

    Step Who does it Cost
    Complete the IRS form (W-9, W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E) The contractor Free from the IRS
    Collect and store the W-9 or W-8BEN RemiPay, at onboarding Included in the RemiPay subscription
    Approve the pay run The founder in RemiPay, with 2FA, recording who approved and when Included in the subscription
    Send each payment You, from your Wise Business account or another provider Transfer fee charged by Wise or the provider
    Mark each payment paid You, in RemiPay Included in the subscription
    Give the bookkeeper the record CSV export from RemiPay Included in the subscription
    Prepare Form 1099-NEC for U.S. contractors You or your accountant Depends on your accountant

    RemiPay's plans are Solo at $19 a month for up to 3 contractors, Starter at $49 for up to 10, and Team at $199 for up to 50. Funds never pass through RemiPay; the transfer fee is the provider's.

    Common questions

    Does a U.S. citizen living abroad fill out a W-9 or a W-8BEN? A W-9. The form follows U.S. tax status, not location. The IRS defines a U.S. person to include U.S. citizens and resident aliens, and its W-8BEN instructions tell U.S. persons to use Form W-9 instead.

    What is the difference between W-8BEN and W-8BEN-E? W-8BEN is for foreign individuals. W-8BEN-E is for foreign entities, such as a contractor's own company registered abroad, to document their status for U.S. withholding purposes.

    Do I send the W-8BEN or W-9 to the IRS? No. You request and keep the form. The IRS instructions say not to send Form W-8BEN to the IRS. A W-9's name and TIN appear on information returns such as Form 1099-NEC; the form itself stays with you.

    How long is a W-8BEN valid? Generally from the signing date until the last day of the third succeeding calendar year, unless a change in circumstances makes it incorrect. The contractor must tell you within 30 days of such a change.

    What happens if a U.S. contractor will not give me a W-9? The IRS says payers must apply backup withholding at a flat 24% on reportable payments when the payee does not furnish a TIN. Confirm the details with a tax professional before paying.

    Sources

    Checked November 16, 2026

    This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Tax status can be more complicated than the cases above (dual-status years, treaty claims, contractors working partly in the U.S.). Please consult a qualified tax professional about your contractors.

    Next steps

    tax-formsw-8benw-9contractor-onboardingresources
    RemiPay Team

    Posts from the RemiPay editorial team. Have a question or topic request? Email hello@remipay.co.