remipay
    Resources

    Contractor vs employee: how to tell, and what you can control

    RemiPay Team··11 min read

    A worker is an employee when your business has the right to control what they do and how they do it, and an independent contractor when you control only the result. The IRS weighs behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship; the Department of Labor asks whether the worker is economically dependent on you. Under both tests, how the work actually happens decides, not the contract's label.

    The IRS test: three categories of evidence

    For federal employment tax, the IRS weighs all the evidence of control and independence; no single factor, and no set number of factors, makes someone an employee. The evidence falls into three groups.

    Category Points toward employee Points toward contractor
    Behavioral control: instructions You set when and where they work, which tools and equipment they use, the order of tasks, and who does the work They decide schedule, location, tools and methods; you describe the result
    Behavioral control: evaluation You measure how the work is done You judge only the end result (the IRS says this alone can fit either)
    Behavioral control: training You train them in your procedures and methods, especially on an ongoing basis They bring their own methods
    Financial control: investment and expenses You supply the equipment and cover their costs They invest in their own equipment and carry their own unreimbursed costs
    Financial control: profit, loss and pay A guaranteed wage by the hour, week or other period They can make or lose money on the work; often a flat fee per job
    Financial control: the market They work only for you They advertise and are free to take other clients
    Type of relationship Benefits such as insurance, a pension or paid time off; an open-ended arrangement; work that is a key part of what your business sells A defined project or period; no employee benefits

    Three IRS nuances matter in practice. The right to control counts even if you never use it. Hourly pay is not decisive: the IRS notes that some fields, such as law, commonly pay contractors by the hour. And a contract calling someone a contractor is not enough; how the parties actually work together decides.

    The Department of Labor test, and state rules

    For minimum wage and overtime under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), the Department of Labor (DOL) uses the economic reality test: is the worker economically dependent on you, or in business for themselves? DOL Fact Sheet 13 (revised March 2024) lists six factors:

    1. Opportunity for profit or loss depending on managerial skill
    2. Investments by the worker and by the business
    3. How permanent the relationship is
    4. The nature and degree of control
    5. Whether the work is integral to the business
    6. The worker's skill and initiative

    The fact sheet says FLSA employment is broader than the common-law control standard, so a worker can pass one test and fail the other, and that a job title, a contractor agreement or a 1099 does not determine status.

    The DOL's guidance on this test is changing. On February 26, 2026, it proposed a rule with five factors, treating control and opportunity for profit or loss as the core ones; the comment period closed on April 28, 2026. Check the DOL rulemaking page for the current status before relying on either version.

    States can apply their own tests. The DOL notes that its proposed rule would not affect stricter state wage-and-hour tests, naming the ABC tests in California and New Jersey, and that employers must follow every federal, state and local law that applies.

    What you can control with a contractor, and what points to employment

    Some control is normal with a contractor: you define what you are buying. The factors point toward employment when you control how, when and where the work is done.

    Usually fine with a contractor Points toward employment
    The deliverable and its acceptance criteria Set working hours or required online hours
    Deadlines and milestones Daily supervision of how tasks are done
    The rate: fixed fee, milestone or an agreed hourly rate A guaranteed salary for an open-ended role
    Quality review of the finished work Performance reviews of methods, attendance or effort
    A notice period and a project end date Indefinite work with no defined scope
    Confidentiality and IP terms in the agreement Company benefits such as insurance, a pension or paid time off
    Hours or invoices submitted for payment Training in your procedures and methods

    Hourly billing is legitimate for contractors; the hours price the work rather than supervise it. See how to review contractor hours before payment.

    For the tax side of each choice, read 1099 vs W-2; for a new contractor's setup, use the contractor onboarding checklist.

    Close monitoring and contractor status

    Screenshots, activity scores and app tracking measure how someone works, not what they deliver, and the IRS treats measuring how work is performed as evidence of behavioral control. Monitoring alone does not make a contractor an employee, but it sits awkwardly with the relationship you are claiming.

    To pay by the hour, a plain timer is usually enough. RemiStaff, the timer built into RemiPay, is a start and stop timer with no screenshots. For trackers with and without monitoring, see Hubstaff alternatives.

    What misclassification risks look like

    The IRS describes the consequences in general terms:

    • Treating a worker as a contractor without a reasonable basis can leave the business owing employment taxes for that worker.
    • Relief may be available with a reasonable basis and consistently filed information returns, but it does not make the worker a contractor.
    • A misclassified worker can report their share of uncollected Social Security and Medicare tax on Form 8919.
    • The Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (Form 8952) offers partial relief from past employment taxes to a business that reclassifies workers going forward.

    On the labor side, the DOL says misclassification can deny workers minimum wage, overtime and other protections, and state consequences vary. If the answer is genuinely unclear, you or the worker can file Form SS-8 (current revision December 2023) for an IRS determination, which the IRS says can take at least six months.

    Contractors outside the U.S.

    The tests above are U.S. federal tests. For a contractor working in another country, local labor law can also decide whether the relationship is employment. If a role abroad looks like employment, an employer of record is one way to hire properly; see what is an employer of record. A genuine foreign contractor who is an individual gives you Form W-8BEN rather than a W-9; see W-8BEN vs W-9.

    Paying a contractor once you have decided

    Once a role is clearly a contractor role, each part of the recurring pay run is priced separately:

    Step Who does it Cost
    Track hours or milestones The contractor, in RemiStaff, Hubstaff or a timesheet Included in the RemiPay subscription
    Approve the pay run The owner in RemiPay, with 2FA; RemiPay records who approved and when Included in the subscription
    Send each payment You, from your Wise Business account, Payoneer, PayPal or bank Transfer fee charged by your provider; check the current quote
    Mark each payment paid You, in RemiPay Included in the subscription
    Give the bookkeeper the record CSV export from RemiPay Included in the subscription

    RemiPay plans are Solo at $19 a month for up to 3 contractors, Starter at $49 for up to 10, and Team at $199 for up to 50; see pricing. Funds never pass through RemiPay, and it charges only its subscription.

    Worked example: three roles at a fictional agency

    This is a sample, illustrative assessment for Harbor & Pine, a fictional 12-person U.S. agency. The facts are invented, and the last row shows how the factors lean, not a legal determination.

    Factor Brand designer for a rebrand Client support coordinator Retained developer
    The role (fictional) Six-week project for a new client logo and style guide Answers client tickets, 9 to 5 Eastern, Monday to Friday About 20 hours a month maintaining client sites
    Instructions Brief and deadlines only; she picks tools and schedule Set shifts, agency scripts, agency help desk Agency sets tasks; he chooses when and how
    Evaluation Final files reviewed against the brief Supervisor reviews response times and methods weekly Work reviewed when tickets close
    Investment and expenses Own software licenses and equipment Agency laptop and software Own equipment; agency gives repository access
    Profit or loss Flat fee per project Hourly, guaranteed 40 hours a week Agreed hourly rate, varying hours
    Other clients Advertises and serves several None Has other clients
    Relationship Ends when files are delivered Open-ended, core to the agency's service Ongoing retainer, no fixed end
    How it leans Contractor Employee Mixed: closer to contractor, but the open-ended retainer and agency-set tasks deserve a second look

    The designer is the clearest contractor. The support coordinator fits almost every employee factor, so Harbor & Pine hires the role on payroll. The developer is the common gray area: the agency replaces the open-ended task list with a defined scope for each quarter and asks its adviser to review the arrangement; if doubt remains, it could file Form SS-8.

    Common questions

    What is the main difference between a contractor and an employee? Control. Under the IRS common-law rules, a business with the right to direct how the work is done has an employee, even if it never uses that right. A business that controls only the result is more likely working with an independent contractor.

    Does a signed independent contractor agreement make someone a contractor? No. The IRS says a contract's label is not enough to decide status, and the Department of Labor says a contractor agreement or a 1099 does not by itself make someone a contractor under the Fair Labor Standards Act. How the work is actually done decides.

    Can I set deadlines and hours for a contractor? You can set deliverables, deadlines and the agreed rate. Telling a contractor when and where to work, which tools to use and in what order to do tasks is behavioral control in the IRS's terms, which points toward employment.

    How do I get an official answer on a worker's status? File Form SS-8. Either the business or the worker can file it, and the IRS determines status for federal employment tax and income tax withholding. The IRS says this can take at least six months.

    What happens if I classify an employee as a contractor by mistake? Per the IRS, a business that treats an employee as a contractor without a reasonable basis may owe employment taxes for that worker. Its Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (Form 8952) offers partial relief to businesses that reclassify workers going forward. Labor law consequences are separate.

    Sources

    Checked November 16, 2026

    This page is general information, not tax or legal advice; for a specific role, ask a qualified tax professional or employment lawyer.

    Next steps

    contractor-classificationindependent-contractoremployment-lawcontractor-onboardingresources
    RemiPay Team

    Posts from the RemiPay editorial team. Have a question or topic request? Email hello@remipay.co.